Torres v. JAI Dining: Inside the Landmark Arizona Dram Shop Case

Torres v. JAI Dining Services (Phoenix), Inc., 252 Ariz. 28 (2021)

Torres v. JAI Dining Services (Phoenix) Inc., 256 Ariz. 212 (2023)

Torres v. JAI Dining Services is the case that set the current rules for dram shop liability in Arizona, and Bailey Law Firm founder Jenna Bailey was one of the attorneys who tried it.

The Arizona Supreme Court decided the case twice. In Torres I (2021), the Court held that a bar’s liability does not end just because an overserved patron made it home; it continues until that person sobers up.

In Torres II (2023), the Court held that the “obvious intoxication” standard in A.R.S. § 4-311 replaces common law negligence in dram shop cases.

For injury victims and grieving families, that means these claims are harder to prove and generally must be filed within one year.

Key Takeaways

  • “Safe at home” is not a defense. Under Torres I, a dram shop’s liability for overservice does not end until the intoxicated person sobers up, and that question goes to the jury.
  • “Obvious intoxication” is the standard. Under Torres II, plaintiffs must prove the establishment served someone who was obviously intoxicated under A.R.S. § 4-311. Common law negligence is no longer a fallback claim.
  • The deadline is one year. Because dram shop liability is created by statute, the statute of limitations is one year, not the two years typical for common law claims.
  • An expert will be needed in most cases to prove obvious intoxication.

What Is a Dram Shop Case in Arizona?

A dram shop is any business licensed to sell alcohol to the public, including bars, nightclubs, restaurants, breweries, wineries, and stores that sell alcohol.

In Arizona, a licensed establishment can be held responsible when it serves alcohol to an obviously intoxicated patron or to a minor, and that service leads to injury or death.

The most common example is a drunk driving crash caused by a patron who was overserved before getting behind the wheel.

Torres v. JAI Dining shaped how every one of these cases is now argued in Arizona courts.

Jenna Bailey’s Role as Trial Attorney in Torres v. JAI Dining Services

In March of 2019, Dominique Barrett, Jenna Bailey, and Darrell Barger litigated this case against the plaintiffs in the Maricopa County Superior Court of Arizona.

The judge, who is now retired, was an exceptional judge for the Court and this matter was litigated to a verdict.

Even at this early stage in her career, Jenna had substantial trial experience which is rare and becoming increasingly uncommon for various reasons.

Shortly after this trial, Jenna left civil defense, started Bailey Law Firm, and now uses that exceptional amount of trial experience as a Tempe personal injury lawyer for the clients she is fortunate enough to represent.

Jenna handled every deposition in the case leading up to trial, including all four experts.

At jury trial, Jenna handled voir dire, opening statement and the examination of half of the lay witnesses and expert witnesses, including plaintiffs’ and defendant’s toxicologist experts.

Torres v. JAI Dining: Case Facts and Procedural History

In the early morning hours of November 8, 2015, Defendant Driver crashed his pickup truck into a vehicle occupied by two young people at a stop light after drinking at a club.

Defendant Driver was served and consumed alcohol at Defendant JAI Dining’s club in Phoenix.

Defendant Driver and his friends started drinking at the club around 9 p.m. and remained at the club until about 2 a.m. on November 8th.

Defendant Driver was then driven from the club to a house where he stopped to “chill out.”

The Defendant Driver then drove to his residence at approximately 4 a.m. and went to sleep.

Sometime after that, Defendant Driver was awakened and asked to drive an acquaintance home.

Defendant Driver agreed, but on his way home he hit the vehicle occupied by two young people, killing both.

Defendant Driver’s blood alcohol content (“BAC”) at the time of the blood draw was approximately 0.110.

The defense toxicologist expert testified that the driver’s BAC when he left the club was between 0.128 and 0.166.

The family of the young woman and young man who were killed brought a negligence claim against Defendant Driver.

The family also brought claims against the club for common law negligence and statutory dram shop liability.

The jury found liability against Defendant Driver and liability against the club for common law negligence, but not for statutory dram shop liability, which would turn out to be devastating for the family.

The verdict was appealed and the Arizona Court of Appeals for Division One reversed that verdict because Defendant Driver’s decision to leave his residence and then drive again was an intervening and superseding cause which relieved the club of negligence and dram shop liability.

The Arizona Supreme Court reviewed the matter and held that the intervening and superseding cause of the occupants’ deaths was actually for the jury to decide.

The case then returned to the Maricopa County Superior Court only to ultimately return to the Arizona Supreme Court to consider the permissibility of common law negligence for dram shop cases.

This time the Arizona Supreme Court held that the common law negligence claim had been abrogated by the state legislature.

The jury only returned a verdict against the club for the common law negligence, and therefore the verdict was reversed.

How the Arizona Supreme Court Ruled in Torres I and Torres II

Torres I, 252 Ariz. 28 (2021): No “Safe at Home” Defense for Bars

In Torres I the Arizona Supreme Court rejected the appellate court’s decision that because the driver made it home safely from the club it was absolved of liability.

The Arizona Supreme Court rejected a “safe at home” argument by the club.

The Court reasoned that when an individual is overserved by a dram shop, liability for that dram shop does not end until the intoxicated individual “sobers up.”

The Arizona Supreme Court confirmed that this issue had to be decided by the jury.

Torres II, 256 Ariz. 212 (2023): “Obvious Intoxication” Is the Standard

In Torres II however, the Arizona Supreme Court agreed with the club.

The Arizona Supreme Court held that common law dram shop liability was preempted by A.R.S. § 4-311. A.R.S. § 4-311 requires a stricter “obvious intoxication” standard than the common law negligence standard.

The jury found the club liable only for the more permissive common law standard and therefore the verdict was reversed.

The Arizona Supreme Court ruled that Arizona’s dram shop statutes and the anti-abrogation constitutional clause only protect common law rights that existed at the time Arizona became a state in 1912.

Dram shop liability was created by a court decision in 1983, so the legislature had authority to replace or restrict it – which it did.

This ruling solidified the “obvious intoxication” standard established by A.R.S. § 4-311 rather than also allowing the “fallback” standard of common law negligence.

What Torres Means for Arizona Dram Shop Claims Today

This decision has far-reaching strategy and statute of limitations consequences for prospective plaintiffs.

A Higher Burden of Proof: Obvious Intoxication

First, the “obvious intoxication” standard is more difficult to prove. An expert will be needed in most actions to establish this prong.

A One-Year Statute of Limitations

Additionally, because this action is statutorily created the statute of limitations is only one-year – not the two years more typical for common law claims.

Therefore, it is imperative that you consider an attorney as soon as possible for these claims.

How Jenna Bailey and Bailey Law Firm Can Help You

Jenna Bailey is the state Chairwoman of the board for Arizona’s MADD chapter, prosecuted vehicular crimes (such as drinking and driving) for the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office, and was one of the attorneys who tried the landmark case Torres v. JAI Dining.

Jenna can assist injured clients and their loved ones grieving from a drunk driving death obtain the justice they deserve.

Although money cannot remedy a death or fully account for catastrophic injuries, a damages award can hold a negligent establishment financially accountable.

The hope is that these financial penalties can reduce – if not eliminate – overservice by other dram shops as well.

Jenna can help her clients successfully navigate the landmines outlined above to ensure that the best possible outcome is obtained for her clients after these truly preventable injuries and deaths.

Learn more about Jenna Bailey.

Frequently Asked Questions About Arizona Dram Shop Law

What is dram shop liability in Arizona?

Dram shop liability is the legal responsibility a licensed establishment has when it serves alcohol to an obviously intoxicated person or a minor and that service causes injury or death.

In Arizona, it is governed by statute, A.R.S. § 4-311, and after Torres II it is the only path to hold a bar or restaurant liable for overservice.

What does “obvious intoxication” mean?

A.R.S. § 4-311(D) defines obvious intoxication as “inebriated to such an extent that a person’s physical faculties are substantially impaired and the impairment is shown by significantly uncoordinated physical action or significant physical dysfunction that would have been obvious to a reasonable person.”

Who can be sued in an Arizona dram shop case?

Licensed establishments that sell alcohol, such as bars, nightclubs, restaurants, and stores, can be held liable along with the intoxicated driver.

Arizona law does not allow these claims against social hosts who serve guests of legal drinking age.

How long do I have to file a dram shop claim in Arizona?

Generally one year.

Because dram shop liability is created by statute, A.R.S. § 12-541(5) sets a one-year statute of limitations, although that time limitation may be tolled for various reasons.

The one-year deadline applies to both wrongful death claims and injury claims.

Does a bar’s liability end once the drunk driver gets home?

No.

In Torres I, the Arizona Supreme Court rejected the “safe at home” argument.

A dram shop’s liability for overservice does not end until the intoxicated person sobers up, and whether the chain of responsibility was broken is a question for the jury.

Talk to an Arizona Dram Shop Attorney

If you or someone you love was injured or killed by a driver who was overserved at a bar or restaurant, the one-year deadline makes timing critical.

Call Bailey Law Firm at 480-681-5408 or request a free case evaluation to discuss your case with our team.

Share this post

Picture of Jenna Bailey

Jenna Bailey

With a decade of experience litigating cases, Jenna has handled hundreds of depositions, dozens of jury trials and countless court appearances. Jenna prides herself on having a stellar reputation among fellow attorneys, colleagues at all levels and judges. Her secret sauce litigation style is a perfect mix of a laid-back “I got this” energy and tough advocacy.
Picture of Jenna Bailey

Jenna Bailey

With a decade of experience litigating cases, Jenna has handled hundreds of depositions, dozens of jury trials and countless court appearances. Jenna prides herself on having a stellar reputation among fellow attorneys, colleagues at all levels and judges. Her secret sauce litigation style is a perfect mix of a laid-back “I got this” energy and tough advocacy.